You are not trashing my design, only challenging it. It's not like other systems don't have flaws of their own too. Anyway, if every best player from every division 2 team made a club I say it's not crazy to have them prove they are for real by beating the next division 2 tournament. But yeah in my system that new team goes in div2. At least it's all set in stone, coz if you're gonna judge where that team plays, div 1 or 2, how do you justify their inclusion in div1, probably at the expense of another team that was supposed to play in div1 before that new club was created? Now you're mistaken about not being able to pick up a good player from a lower division because basically the guy's weight in the new team value would pull it down from, say, 1 to 0.85 which is still above lower division team values that are around 0. 0.85 and 1 are essentially the same result because it doesn't matter if your team is 1st or 12th in a 12-team division, they will both go to the same division. This is the very reason it doesn't matter that the values players carry doesn't have to very accurately reflect their skill and you shouldn't interpret them as such like Connor keeps doing. That, of course, is unless there is an enormous amount of player movement which will not happen anyway, and if there are many many divisions which also will not happen anyway. Feel free to challenge my creation again and again. I reckon the more you challenge it, the more you'll realize it's the best